Between Hirsch and Sizer, the debate seems to stress what the content of classes should truly be about. "Students should be able to read and know basic number facts by the end of the first grade." Hirsch argues that students should be prepared with common knowledge early, and that they should stress the student's ability to retain and recite necessary information. Hirsch maintains that this kind of number-crunching and basic understanding of literacy will be adequate preparation for the concrete, regimented workforce.
Sizer would argue that this basic information is necessary up until high school, where Sizer says "Students should leave school as well-informed skeptics, able to ask good questions as a matter of habit." Sizer's entire point is that students should not only know things but be able to understand them and question what makes them tick. Sizer's main argument with Hirsch is that his form of education is to focused on simple knowledge, with not enough focus on understanding and questioning.
1. Do these theories contradict each other? Intellectually, emotionally, practically? In what ways do they? Could they be adapted to work together?
I think that in a practical way of thinking, Hirsch's method of schooling benefits the student greater when they are trying to join the workforce and when they work jobs that require less broad thinking and more repetition and recalling fact. I also think that this method is more emotionally draining, as the students are just forced to crunch information and recite and repeat as they are told. There is little room in this method for dreaming and growing intellectually. Sizer's method of thinking of things as developmental and curious benefits the student's natural wonder for things, and urges the students to push deeper and really marinate in their thoughts, always rethinking and re-imagining why they are taught what they are, and how it can ultimately benefit them.
2. Which of the two theories do you find more resonant in your own experience? Has your education at one of Sizer's schools (he not only inspired SOF, he also came and visited) taught you to use your mind well, to be intellectually alert, to be able to think about important aspects of your life and society? Have you had any teachers that seemed inspired, now that you know about it, by Hirsch? For instance, would you say that the chemistry class's focus on molarity and ions and the periodic table of elements create an emphasis on knowledge?
I can clearly see the general Sizer method that we have in place at SOF. We are told to think, to question, to seek insight and meaning in our work. I feel that this is mostly prevalent in our history and english classes. We have a lot of work that involves reflecting on our own work, and even much of that is pushed to be creative in terms of how we present it. Even our exhibitions are Sizeresque. We employ the habits of mind to draw as much meaning from source material as possible. Point of view is one of the biggest concepts we learn to use in papers and presentations, and is useful information to carry with us into real life outside of school.
I used to go to a catholic school, and now that I know these methods, I can see clearly how my old school was a Hirsch dream school. We had everything regimented. The seating order, the material, and the pace at which we moved in our lessons allowed little forgiveness for kids who needed extra help or kids who were ahead of the curve. Hirsch's narrow focus on basic information only really appeals to students in the middle 50 percentile, whereas the top and bottom 25%s get left out.
3. What additional points does reading these theorists make you think of, about your own education and philosophy?
I think that if I had been offered the choice between the two methods of teaching when I was young, I ould certainly have picked Sixer's approach. Sizer seeks genuine learning and understanding of topics, and allows for thought in the classroom. I feel the Hirsch does the opposite. Of course, I am naturally inclined to think so because I go to a Sizer school, and there are many people who would disagree with me, but I feel personally it is more beneficial for me to be allowed to dream and rationalize my own thoughts in my own way.
Thursday, April 15, 2010
Flashback scene
Script for teacher film
In class flashback
Teacher: You see, much of early american writing largely focused on man's basic need for his fellow man,
Disruptive student: Yo that's mad gay! (laughter)
Teacher (continuing): Early american poets like Walt Whitman chose to exemplify the basic understanding for one another that people have by simply walking alongside them on a crowded new York city street. Whitman wrote many 'walking poems' in which the concept was that everyone is connected, separate only by our innate awkwardness.
Rebellious Student: That's full of shit- I think that insights from dead poets dont relate in our current context where we have things like cell phones, AIM, and other shit that keeps us totally connected to our friends, the important people in our lives. Whitman had nothing better to do than walk around the city, so of course he wanted to make it sound more interesting.
Teacher: That's a fair point- there isn't much to be said for interpersonal communication when people have all these multimedia devices keeping them synced into one anothers lives all day long. But think about it. When you are texting or calling whoever it is you talk to, you miss out on everything around you. The only way to make any new friends is to spend some time away from the old ones. Go outside and talk to people for once. In fact, the odds are that you're too afraid to do what these dead poets have done, and you feel much safer with your cell phone security blanket.
Class: Ooooooooohhhhh!
In class flashback
Teacher: You see, much of early american writing largely focused on man's basic need for his fellow man,
Disruptive student: Yo that's mad gay! (laughter)
Teacher (continuing): Early american poets like Walt Whitman chose to exemplify the basic understanding for one another that people have by simply walking alongside them on a crowded new York city street. Whitman wrote many 'walking poems' in which the concept was that everyone is connected, separate only by our innate awkwardness.
Rebellious Student: That's full of shit- I think that insights from dead poets dont relate in our current context where we have things like cell phones, AIM, and other shit that keeps us totally connected to our friends, the important people in our lives. Whitman had nothing better to do than walk around the city, so of course he wanted to make it sound more interesting.
Teacher: That's a fair point- there isn't much to be said for interpersonal communication when people have all these multimedia devices keeping them synced into one anothers lives all day long. But think about it. When you are texting or calling whoever it is you talk to, you miss out on everything around you. The only way to make any new friends is to spend some time away from the old ones. Go outside and talk to people for once. In fact, the odds are that you're too afraid to do what these dead poets have done, and you feel much safer with your cell phone security blanket.
Class: Ooooooooohhhhh!
Monday, April 12, 2010
Homework 47 - Ideas
I think that to address the idea of the super-teacher without being to dry and too cliche, we need to stir up the original formula so that it's still appealing, but at least a little bit more....colorful.
1.) For shooting, since we are already filming at amateur status, we can accomplish the idea of a somewhat grainy, low-level feel to the setting and tone.
2.) I really like the idea of switch lighting. By that I mean that we should begin in a dark place, dimly lit (by sunlight through windows to send the message of being partially separate from 'the light') and with a low, somber tone. Scene switches can work through flashbacks to better days, where the light will pick up, and thus the tone as well.
3) I think the teacher needs earthly flaws that will ultimately exemplify the good characteristics of his, well, character. Alcoholism, while cliche, shows the mortality of the protagonist and the demons he/she deals with.
4) Nothing draws audiences closer to the character than empathy. I want to play up that concept- there has to be some major tragedy in the life of super teacher. Perhaps his fiance dies, or his wife, or his best friend. I really feel like it has to be a genuine tragedy, which means death, or some kind of finality. It can't be cancer, because while tragic, cancer patients have some small hope of recovery, or remission. Death is the way to go, which in turn can drive him/her to alchoholism.
5) Several key students. We have had the rebel student exemplified in every movie we've watched, and while he typically has a good supporting cast, he obviously leads. I want class rivalries between dynamically opposed characters. Conflict is key/ we can't have a dull script.
6) Teacher social life. If the teacher has friends and people to meet and be with, he's like us. He goes out on friday nights to do as he pleases, and he has things to do that are important to him. If he has a booming social cirlce, we all like him more. He can't be sop devoted to his class that the social conflict comes from lack of attention to the important people in his life.
1.) For shooting, since we are already filming at amateur status, we can accomplish the idea of a somewhat grainy, low-level feel to the setting and tone.
2.) I really like the idea of switch lighting. By that I mean that we should begin in a dark place, dimly lit (by sunlight through windows to send the message of being partially separate from 'the light') and with a low, somber tone. Scene switches can work through flashbacks to better days, where the light will pick up, and thus the tone as well.
3) I think the teacher needs earthly flaws that will ultimately exemplify the good characteristics of his, well, character. Alcoholism, while cliche, shows the mortality of the protagonist and the demons he/she deals with.
4) Nothing draws audiences closer to the character than empathy. I want to play up that concept- there has to be some major tragedy in the life of super teacher. Perhaps his fiance dies, or his wife, or his best friend. I really feel like it has to be a genuine tragedy, which means death, or some kind of finality. It can't be cancer, because while tragic, cancer patients have some small hope of recovery, or remission. Death is the way to go, which in turn can drive him/her to alchoholism.
5) Several key students. We have had the rebel student exemplified in every movie we've watched, and while he typically has a good supporting cast, he obviously leads. I want class rivalries between dynamically opposed characters. Conflict is key/ we can't have a dull script.
6) Teacher social life. If the teacher has friends and people to meet and be with, he's like us. He goes out on friday nights to do as he pleases, and he has things to do that are important to him. If he has a booming social cirlce, we all like him more. He can't be sop devoted to his class that the social conflict comes from lack of attention to the important people in his life.
Hw 48 - Treatment on the teacher film
An empty classroom, the lights turned off, with only the natural light of the bright sun shining through the somewhat dirty windows lighting the room. Once-great teacher is at his desk, packing his possessions into a cardboard file box. His demeanor reflects a great burden almost physically weighing him down. He picks up a picture of his late girlfriend. He decides to sit down for a minute, to collect himself for the rest of the day. From the bottom drawer of his desk, he pulls a bottle of liquor and a small glass. Pouring himself a few fingers of the murky liquid, he leans back in his chair and closes his eyes. Everything is quiet. The only sounds are his breathing.
Flash back to some previous time. The teacher is in the middle of class, demonstrating to his students the significance of interpersonal relationships. Some of the students are jaded in typical teenage fashion, and make it obvious to the class their distaste for the material. Amongst scoffing and snickers from the 'rebellious' crowd, the teacher maintains his calm, cool state. Eventually one student interrupts his presentation to interject a remarkably insightful, if rude, comment. The teacher pauses to think, then responds in kind, with insightful advice layered in a sarcastic coating. The class laughs as a whole, and the teacher resumes his lecture.
Back to present. Teacher has the bottle half finished, and sitting behind his desk, he puts his head down into his hands and sobs.
Flash back to some previous time. The teacher is in the middle of class, demonstrating to his students the significance of interpersonal relationships. Some of the students are jaded in typical teenage fashion, and make it obvious to the class their distaste for the material. Amongst scoffing and snickers from the 'rebellious' crowd, the teacher maintains his calm, cool state. Eventually one student interrupts his presentation to interject a remarkably insightful, if rude, comment. The teacher pauses to think, then responds in kind, with insightful advice layered in a sarcastic coating. The class laughs as a whole, and the teacher resumes his lecture.
Back to present. Teacher has the bottle half finished, and sitting behind his desk, he puts his head down into his hands and sobs.
Monday, March 1, 2010
Homework 42
I think the concept of tracking classes is a healthy one; but it's important to know where to draw the line. Being in a tracked class, I can attest to the power of assembling students who are close in academic range to one another. I would put myself in the 50th percentile amongst my classmates, so being behind some, but ahead of some as well. When grouped with people who can understand the material when I myself may not necessarily grasp it completely, I feel myself encouraged to work harder to get a better grasp on the material. However, I feel that to mix classes too largely would throw off the balance; there would be a certain rift in the formula, with some students so far behind they give up, disheartened by the 'smarter' students, and at the same time, the 'smart' kids are so far ahead they aren't feeling challenged enough. I feel that tracking works best by isolating the highest percentile and grouping them together, with a max of a 10% difference. By this I mean grouping children from between the 99th percentile to the 89th percentile, and so on, and so on. By maintaining classes with students withing reachable intellectual range of one another, growth is not only encouraged by teachers, but truthfully sought after by the students themselves. Tell a smart kid that they aren't quite as smart as their peer, and they will strive until they feel that it is no longer the case. Same goes for any kid who is in the same grouping.
Thursday, February 25, 2010
Blog 41
I am attempting research into the eternal questions that all parents invariably face; is it ultimatley better to put my child in a private or a public school? Parents are told to weigh the options, looking for what they feel would be best appropriate for their own kids. Personally, I came into public school at 8th grade, having a solid 8 years in a parochial private school. (Well, actually two parochial private schools) I know the essential gist of ow these two systems can operate, and so I understand the selling points that come with both of them.
My internet research turned up some interesting articles;
http://www.publicschoolreview.com/articles/5 - an article that chooses to focus on the balance of pros and cons in both systems
http://www.greatschools.org/find-a-school/defining-your-ideal/private-vs-public-schools.gs?content=59 - a somehwat shortsighted, yet relevant article focused more on the reasons why the debate is even a debate
I recently read an article in Page 11 magazine in this past Sunday New York Times that, while not relevant to my research question, was still an interesting perspective on schools. I wasn't able to track it down online, but essentially the article spoke of a legislator in one of the western states who proposed getting rid of the whole senior year of high school. The journalist who wrote the article was heavily biased towards the concept of getting rid of the "unnecessary" year and generally heavily opposed to teenagers in general. I somewhat agree with the idea of only three years of high school, but at the same time, I understand the opposition. (The idea was met with overwhelming disdain) To leave high school friends beind is no easy task for a high schooler, and senior year is the buffer that makes it easier. This is the last time we all spend together, so why not make it last?
My internet research turned up some interesting articles;
http://www.publicschoolreview.com/articles/5 - an article that chooses to focus on the balance of pros and cons in both systems
http://www.greatschools.org/find-a-school/defining-your-ideal/private-vs-public-schools.gs?content=59 - a somehwat shortsighted, yet relevant article focused more on the reasons why the debate is even a debate
I recently read an article in Page 11 magazine in this past Sunday New York Times that, while not relevant to my research question, was still an interesting perspective on schools. I wasn't able to track it down online, but essentially the article spoke of a legislator in one of the western states who proposed getting rid of the whole senior year of high school. The journalist who wrote the article was heavily biased towards the concept of getting rid of the "unnecessary" year and generally heavily opposed to teenagers in general. I somewhat agree with the idea of only three years of high school, but at the same time, I understand the opposition. (The idea was met with overwhelming disdain) To leave high school friends beind is no easy task for a high schooler, and senior year is the buffer that makes it easier. This is the last time we all spend together, so why not make it last?
Monday, February 22, 2010
Blog 40
Interviews With People About School (No Imaginative Title today.)
Interview With P. McCarthy (Dad)
Do you think that students get a better education from a private institution or a public one? Why?
Private. Less children in a classroom, the private school system have more resources, and therefore better equipped to provide. Public schools are to tied by bureaucracy, and while they may be fantastic individually, they fall down together.
How important do you value education for your children? To what lengths would you go to achieve the best possible level of education?
On a scale of 1-10? 10. It's not the lengths that I would go, it's the lengths my children are willing to go. Parents don't educate kids, they just put them in a position where they can be educated.
What do you think of homeschool?
I thinks it's highly impractical. Somebody then has to be at home, and that person has to be better educated in most disciples than ordinary teachers.
I think kids that aren't self motivated, for them it doesn't matter what school they go to. They're either intellectually curious or they aren't.
Can you make a kid intellectually curious?
not that i know of, schools offer a various selection of branches of intellectual curiosity, and its up to the kids to find them interesting. A certain amount of that has to do with what you do with your kids as they are young, ie reading to them or something.
If it would present a better opportunity for students to learn would you move?
provided that they were self motivate,d I would absolutely move. I think that tuition also shouldn't be a barrier from preventing kids from reaching their maximum potential.
What material do you think is the best to teach students?
Should they cater to an individual interest?
schools should have a well rounded curriculum, broad-based. at least for high school level, and college becomes the place where they can choose their own individual paths.
What do you think of the broad based material that we all tend to learn in high school? what kind of relevance does it hold for you, an adult out of college?
you can have a conversation with anyone; you dont have to be like duh. it makes you articulate and able to hold up in conversation. the stuff that is important lasts, the stuff that gets used lasts.
Interview With P. McCarthy (Dad)
Do you think that students get a better education from a private institution or a public one? Why?
Private. Less children in a classroom, the private school system have more resources, and therefore better equipped to provide. Public schools are to tied by bureaucracy, and while they may be fantastic individually, they fall down together.
How important do you value education for your children? To what lengths would you go to achieve the best possible level of education?
On a scale of 1-10? 10. It's not the lengths that I would go, it's the lengths my children are willing to go. Parents don't educate kids, they just put them in a position where they can be educated.
What do you think of homeschool?
I thinks it's highly impractical. Somebody then has to be at home, and that person has to be better educated in most disciples than ordinary teachers.
I think kids that aren't self motivated, for them it doesn't matter what school they go to. They're either intellectually curious or they aren't.
Can you make a kid intellectually curious?
not that i know of, schools offer a various selection of branches of intellectual curiosity, and its up to the kids to find them interesting. A certain amount of that has to do with what you do with your kids as they are young, ie reading to them or something.
If it would present a better opportunity for students to learn would you move?
provided that they were self motivate,d I would absolutely move. I think that tuition also shouldn't be a barrier from preventing kids from reaching their maximum potential.
What material do you think is the best to teach students?
Should they cater to an individual interest?
schools should have a well rounded curriculum, broad-based. at least for high school level, and college becomes the place where they can choose their own individual paths.
What do you think of the broad based material that we all tend to learn in high school? what kind of relevance does it hold for you, an adult out of college?
you can have a conversation with anyone; you dont have to be like duh. it makes you articulate and able to hold up in conversation. the stuff that is important lasts, the stuff that gets used lasts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)